Home » 2009 » March

Archive for March, 2009:


Active Cases

1.  Cerebral Palsy.  We represent a family whose young child has spastic diplegia cerebral palsy.  During her pregnancy with this child, the mother had mild hypertension (high blood pressure), and was put on the beta-blocker Atenolol, which is known to be potentially harmful to the fetus, and is not recommended for use in pregnancy.  Also, there was very little fetal surveillance in the third trimester.  

At 37 weeks gestation, the mother sensed that her fetus was not moving or moving as much.  She immediately called her obstetrician, who told her to go to the hospital right away.  When the fetal monitors were applied, the fetal heart rythym was non-reassuring (non-reactive).  After several hours in the hospital, an on-call obstetrician arrived and delivered the baby via cesarian section.  Upon entering the uterus, the OB noted very little amniotic fluid (a condition known as oligohydramnios).  The baby had respiratory distress and was transferred to a hospital better equiped to handle these situations.

The child has cerebral palsy, and is permanently impaired.  He probably will never walk, live independently, and is probably mentally handicapped.

2.  Massive Stroke.  We represent the family of a gentleman who underwent a procedure to correct a condition known as Atrial Fibrillation.  Our client had atrial fibrillation for many years before this procedure, and had taken the blood thinner Coumadin, 5 mg/day.  

The procedure failed in that the patient returned to atrial fibrillation about 24 hours after the procedure.  Although the patient had taken 5 mg of Coumadin a day for many years, the surgeon instead put him on .5 mg, or 1/10 the customary dose.  About 1 week later, our client had a massive stroke, rendering him permanently impaired (left sided paralysis, inability to express himself, inability to live independently).  He requires 24 h/day care.

Kelsey Young.  We represent the estate of Kelsey Young, who was 20 years old and died from H1N1.  Kelsey was pregnant and presented to Dublin Methodist Hospital with flu symptoms.  The standard of care is to give Tamiflu to patients with suspected H1N1.  This was not done.  Instead, the emergency physician relied on the rapid antigen test in deciding whether to give Tamiflu.  That is a mistake because there are many false negatives with the rapid tests; in fact, many hospitals do not even use the rapid tests for this very reason.  Kelsey was discharged from the hospital.  Three days later — her symptoms getting worse — she presented to Doctors Hospital, where she eventually was diagnosed with H1N1, but by then it was too late; Kelsey died at Doctors Hospital.     

Keywords: Medical Malpractice; Medical Negligence; Malpractice; Pregnancy; Birth Injury; Cerebral Palsy, Oligohydramnios; spastic diplegia; spastic quadriplegia; Atenolol; Beta-Blocker; Fetal Surveillance; handicap; stroke; heart attack; myocardial infarction; atrial fibrillation; coumadin; peripheral vascular disease; H1N1; flu; influenza.



Practice Areas

My practice is limited to:

Serious Injuries/Wrongful Death resulting from:

Serving the following counties in Ohio:

Adams County · Allen County · Ashland County · Ashtabula County · Athens County · Auglaize County · Belmont County Brown County Butler County Carroll County Champaign County Clark County Clermont County Clinton County Columbiana County Coshocton County Crawford County Cuyahoga County Darke County Defiance County Delaware County Erie County Fairfield County Fayette County Franklin County Fulton County Gallia County Geauga County Greene County Guernsey County Hamilton County Hancock County Hardin County Harrison County Henry County Highland County Hocking County Holmes County Huron County Jackson County Jefferson County Knox County Lake County Lawrence County Licking County Logan County Lorain County Lucas County Madison County Mahoning County Marion County Medina County Meigs County Mercer County Miami County Monroe County Montgomery County Morgan County Morrow County Muskingum County Noble County Ottawa County Paulding County Perry County Pickaway County Pike County Portage County Preble County Putnam County Richland County Ross County Sandusky County Scioto County Seneca County Shelby County Stark County Summit County Trumbull County Tuscarawas County Union County Van Wert County Vinton County Warren County Washington County Wayne County Williams County Wood County Wyandot County

Serving the following cities in Ohio:

Akron Alliance Amherst Ashland Ashtabula Athens Aurora Austintown Avon Avon Lake Barberton Bay Village Beachwood Beavercreek Beckett Ridge Bedford Bedford Heights Bellbrook Bellefontaine Bellevue Belpre Berea Bexley Blacklick Estates Blue Ash Boardman Bowling Green Brecksville Bridgetown North Broadview Heights Brook Park Brooklyn Brunswick Bryan Bucyrus Cambridge Campbell Canfield Canton Celina Centerville Cheviot Chillicothe Cincinnati Circleville Clayton Cleveland Cleveland Heights Clyde Columbus Conneaut Cortland Coshocton Covedale Cuyahoga Falls Dayton Defiance Delaware Delphos Dent Dover Dry Run Dublin East Cleveland East Liverpool Eastlake Eaton Elyria Englewood Euclid Fairborn Fairfield Fairlawn Fairview Park Findlay Finneytown Forest Park Forestville Fostoria Franklin Fremont Gahanna Galion Garfield Heights Geneva Girard Grandview Heights Green Greenville Groesbeck Grove City Hamilton Harrison Heath Highland Heights Hilliard Hillsboro Howland Center Hubbard Huber Heights Hudson Huron Independence Ironton Jackson Kent Kenton Kenwood Kettering Kirtland Lakewood Lancaster Landen Lebanon Lima Lincoln Village Logan London Lorain Louisville Loveland Lyndhurst Macedonia Madeira Mansfield Maple Heights Marietta Marion Martins Ferry Marysville Mason Massillon Maumee Mayfield Heights Medina Mentor Mentor-on-the-Lake Miamisburg Middleburg Heights Middletown Milford Monroe Montgomery Moraine Mount Healthy Mount Vernon Napoleon New Philadelphia Newark Niles North Canton North College Hill North Madison North Olmsted North Ridgeville North Royalton Northbrook Northgate Northridge Norton Norwalk Norwood Oakwood Oberlin Olmsted Falls Oregon Orrville Oxford Painesville Parma Parma Heights Pataskala Pepper Pike Perry Heights Perrysburg Pickerington Piqua Port Clinton Portage Lakes Portsmouth Powell Ravenna Reading Reynoldsburg Richmond Heights Rittman Riverside Rocky River Rossford Salem Sandusky Sandusky South Seven Hills Shaker Heights Sharonville Sheffield Lake Shelby Shiloh Sidney Solon South Euclid Springboro Springdale Springfield St. Marys Steubenville Stow Streetsboro Strongsville Struthers Sylvania Tallmadge Tiffin Tipp City Toledo Trenton Trotwood Troy Twinsburg University Heights Upper Arlington Upper Sandusky Urbana Van Wert Vandalia Vermilion Wadsworth Wapakoneta Warren Warrensville Heights Washington Wauseon Wellston West Carrollton City Westerville Westlake Wheelersburg White Oak Whitehall Wickliffe Willard Willoughby Willoughby Hills Willowick Wilmington Woodbourne-Hyde Park Wooster Worthington Wright-Patterson AFB Wyoming Xenia Youngstown Zanesville

Posted under Personal Injury



Negligence Per Se

Negligence is a failure to do what the reasonable person would do under the same or similar circumstances.  We also refer to this as the “standard of care.”  The standard of care to be exercised for the protection of others can be established by legislative enactment, judicial decision, or by the facts and circumstances of the case.

Where a statute or ordinance imposes a specific duty, or prohibits certain conduct, for the protection of others, and the failure to perform that duty, or the violation of the prohibited act, results in injury to another, the person is “negligent per se” or negligent “as a matter of law.”  See Eisenhuth v. Moneyhon (1954), 161 Ohio St. 367; Swoboda v. Brown (1935), 129 Ohio St. 512.

The violation of an administrative rule does not constitute negligence per se; however, such a violation may be admissible as evidence of negligence.  Chambers v. St. Mary’s School (1998), 82 Ohio St.3d 563; Lang v. Holly Hill Motel, Inc., 122 Ohio St.3d 120, 2009-Ohio-2495 (The open and obvious doctrine may be asserted as a defense to a claim of liability arising from a violation of the Ohio Basic Building Code.”)



© Jeffrey Beausay
CyberChimps